21 Once-Common Workplace Practices That Would Be Illegal Today
In the ever-evolving landscape of employment laws and regulations, certain workplace practices that were once commonplace are now considered illegal. These changes reflect society’s growing awareness of employee rights and the need for fair and equitable treatment in the workplace. Here are 21 practices that have been phased out due to legal developments and shifting societal norms:
This post may contain affiliate links meaning I get commissions for purchases made in this post. Read my disclosure policy here.
Mandatory Retirement
Before the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, employers could enforce mandatory retirement ages, unfairly sidelining older workers from the workforce based solely on age. This practice, rooted in ageism, limited opportunities for experienced individuals to continue contributing their skills and knowledge. The Act sought to rectify this injustice by prohibiting age-based hiring, firing, and promotions.
Segregation and Discrimination
Before the Civil Rights Act of 1964, workplaces were marred by systemic racial segregation and discrimination, perpetuating inequality and hindering the advancement of minorities. African Americans, Hispanics, and other marginalized groups faced overt barriers to employment opportunities and were relegated to menial roles with limited prospects for growth. The Civil Rights Act marked a pivotal moment in US history, outlawing discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.
Gender-Based Job Listings
In the not-so-distant past, job postings frequently included gender preferences, effectively excluding women from certain professions and perpetuating gender stereotypes. This discriminatory practice reinforced the notion that specific roles were inherently suited to one gender over another, limiting career options and perpetuating inequality in the workplace. Legislative measures such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and subsequent anti-discrimination laws have since banned gender-based job listings.
Pay Discrimination
For decades, women and minorities got unequal pay for equal work. Employers consistently undervalue the work of female and minority employees, paying them lower wages compared to their male counterparts. The passage of the Equal Pay Act of 1963 was a monumental achievement in the fight for gender equality, prohibiting wage disparities based on sex for substantially similar work. Despite some progress, the gender pay gap persists, highlighting the ongoing need to combat pay discrimination.
Child Labor
Throughout much of US history, child labor was pervasive, with children as young as five or six toiling in factories, mines, and other hazardous workplaces. These young workers endured long hours, dangerous conditions, and low wages, sacrificing their childhoods for economic necessity. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 represented a watershed moment in child labor reform, establishing minimum age requirements, restricting work hours, and prioritizing education over exploitative employment.
No Overtime Pay
Before the implementation of overtime regulations, many employees were subjected to grueling work schedules without adequate compensation for overtime hours. Employers exploited their workers’ labor, expecting them to work excessive hours without offering fair remuneration for their time and effort. The Fair Labor Standards Act introduced overtime pay provisions, mandating premium pay for hours worked beyond the standard 40-hour workweek.
Unsafe Working Conditions
Without robust workplace safety regulations, employees faced unsafe working conditions, with little recourse for addressing hazards and preventing accidents. Industries such as mining, manufacturing, and construction were particularly notorious for their lax safety standards, resulting in countless injuries, illnesses, and fatalities. The establishment of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) in 1970 heralded a new era of workplace safety, empowering workers to advocate for safer conditions and holding employers accountable for providing a hazard-free environment.
Forced Labor
Throughout history, forced labor has been a dark stain on the fabric of society, depriving individuals of their freedom and dignity. Employers coerced workers into labor through various means, including physical violence, threats, and debt bondage, perpetuating cycles of exploitation and abuse. Legal frameworks such as the Trafficking Victims Protection Act and international conventions against forced labor aim to eradicate this practice, imposing criminal penalties on perpetrators and providing support services for victims.
Unpaid Internships
While internships offer valuable opportunities for skill development and industry exposure, they have come under scrutiny for potentially violating minimum wage laws and perpetuating economic inequality. Some employers exploit unpaid interns’ labor, assigning tasks indistinguishable from those of paid employees without providing any form of compensation.
Excessive Surveillance
With technological advancements, employers have gained unprecedented capabilities to monitor their employees’ activities, raising concerns about privacy rights and workplace autonomy. Surveillance practices such as video monitoring, keystroke logging, and GPS tracking were often implemented without adequate safeguards or transparency, creating distrust and intrusion.
Blanket Non-Disclosure Agreements
Employers have long used non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to protect sensitive information and trade secrets. Still, overly broad NDAs have been criticized for stifling whistleblowing and silencing victims of harassment and discrimination. Employees were sometimes compelled to sign NDAs that prohibited them from discussing workplace issues, including instances of misconduct or illegal behavior. Recent legal reforms and public scrutiny have prompted greater scrutiny of NDAs.
Weight and Appearance Requirements
In specific industries, particularly those centered on appearance or customer service, employers historically imposed weight and appearance standards that discriminated against individuals based on their physical attributes. Women, in particular, faced pressure to conform to unrealistic beauty standards, leading to body shaming and discrimination in hiring and retention practices.
Mandatory Pregnancy Testing
In a blatant violation of privacy rights and gender equality principles, some employers require female job applicants to undergo pregnancy testing as a condition of employment. This invasive practice subjected women to discriminatory treatment based on their reproductive status. Legal challenges and advocacy efforts have sought to outlaw mandatory pregnancy testing, affirming women’s rights to equal treatment in the hiring process and protecting them from discriminatory practices that undermine their reproductive freedom.
Exclusionary Hiring Practices
Individuals with disabilities have long faced discrimination in the labor market, encountering barriers to employment and advancement based on stereotypes and misconceptions. Employers routinely excluded qualified candidates with disabilities from job opportunities, perpetuating systemic inequality and depriving businesses of valuable talent. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) sought to dismantle these barriers by prohibiting discrimination against individuals with disabilities in all aspects of employment.
Hostile Work Environment
Unprofessional behavior, such as harassment and bullying, has no place in a professional workplace. However, for a long time, these practices were accepted or overlooked, resulting in hostile work conditions that negatively impacted the well-being and productivity of employees. Victims of harassment often suffered in silence, fearing retaliation or dismissal if they spoke out against their tormentors. Legal frameworks such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and state anti-discrimination laws have sought to combat workplace harassment by holding employers accountable for preventing and addressing hostile work environments.
No Paid Sick Leave
Before implementing paid sick leave laws, many employees faced the impossible choice between their health and their livelihood: They were forced to work while ill or risk losing wages and employment. This lack of paid sick leave disproportionately affected low-wage workers, who could not afford unpaid time off for illness or caregiving responsibilities. Paid sick leave laws address this inequity by guaranteeing workers the right to accrue and use paid time off for illness, medical appointments, and family caregiving.
Non-Compete Agreements for Low-Wage Workers
Non-compete agreements have traditionally been used to protect employers’ legitimate business interests. However, they have also been misused to restrict workers’ mobility and suppress wage competition. Low-wage workers, in particular, have been disproportionately affected by non-compete agreements that limit their ability to seek employment with competitors or start their businesses.
Invasive Background Checks
While background checks serve a legitimate purpose in screening job applicants for certain positions, they must be conducted responsibly and by applicable laws and regulations. Invasive background checks that delve into an individual’s personal life, including their criminal history, credit score, and private activities, raise concerns about privacy rights and potential discrimination. Legal frameworks such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act and state laws governing background checks seek to protect applicants’ rights and ensure that background checks are conducted fairly, transparently, and without biases.
Unfair Termination Practices
The arbitrary termination of employees without valid cause or due process undermines job security and erodes trust between employers and employees. Without legal protections, employees were vulnerable to unfair dismissal based on arbitrary criteria or discriminatory motives. Employment laws and regulations now require employers to provide valid reasons for termination and afford employees procedural safeguards, such as notice and opportunity to be heard, before taking adverse employment actions.
Denial of Family Leave
Before the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) was enacted, many employees were denied the opportunity to take time off work to care for themselves or their family members during times of need. The lack of job-protected leave forced employees to choose between their caregiving responsibilities and their livelihoods, perpetuating economic insecurity and exacerbating family stress.
Retaliation Against Whistleblowers
Whistleblowers play a critical role in exposing wrongdoing and promoting accountability in the workplace, yet they often face retaliation and reprisals for speaking out against misconduct. Employers may retaliate against whistleblowers by subjecting them to harassment, demotion, termination, or blocklisting, creating a chilling effect that silences dissent and perpetuates a culture of secrecy. Whistleblower protection laws aim to safeguard employees from retaliation for reporting illegal or unethical behavior, providing legal remedies and recourse for individuals who speak truth to power.
