Beauty pageants have been a staple of American culture for decades. However, as societal norms evolve, many past beauty pageants would spark intense debates if held today. From controversial judging criteria to outdated beauty standards, here are 10 beauty pageants from the past that would ignite furious debates in today’s society.

This post may contain affiliate links meaning I get commissions for purchases made in this post. Read my disclosure policy here.

Miss America 1968

The protests against the 1968 Miss America pageant underscored deep-seated concerns about the objectification of women and the perpetuation of narrow beauty standards. Critics argued that the swimsuit competition and emphasis on physical appearance reinforced societal pressures on women to conform to unrealistic ideals. Today, such a pageant would undoubtedly spark furious debates about the objectification of women, body positivity, and the need to redefine beauty standards to be more inclusive.

Miss Navajo Nation 1999

While the Miss Navajo Nation pageant has been celebrated for its cultural significance and promotion of Navajo traditions, it has also faced criticism for reinforcing traditional gender roles and expectations. Critics argue that the emphasis on domestic skills and conformity to cultural norms perpetuates stereotypes and limits the representation of Navajo women.

Miss Trans America 2014

The concept of a pageant exclusively for transgender women, such as Miss Trans America, raises complex questions about inclusivity, representation, and the objectification of transgender bodies. While supporters argue that such pageants provide a platform for transgender individuals to celebrate their identities and talents, critics contend that they perpetuate the focus on physical appearance and reinforce societal expectations of gender conformity.

Miss Rheingold 1959

Once a famous beer-sponsored beauty pageant, Miss Rheingold exemplified the objectification of women as marketing tools for alcoholic beverages. Critics argue that the pageant promoted harmful stereotypes and normalized alcohol consumption as part of feminine allure. Today, such a pageant would face fierce debates about the exploitation of women for commercial gain, the promotion of unhealthy behaviors, and the need for responsible advertising practices.

Miss Beautiful Hair 1985

The Miss Beautiful Hair pageant epitomized the narrow focus on physical appearance and the objectification of women based solely on their hair. Critics argue that reducing women to their physical attributes perpetuates harmful stereotypes and undermines their value beyond appearance. In today’s society, debates center on redefining beauty standards to encompass a broader range of qualities and talents and promote self-worth and confidence independent of external appearance.

Miss Atomic Bomb 1950s

The Miss Atomic Bomb pageant capitalized on the public fascination with nuclear technology after World War II, featuring contestants in swimsuits inspired by mushroom clouds. Critics argue that such pageants trivialized the devastating effects of nuclear warfare and promoted a tasteless form of entertainment. In today’s society, debates focus on the ethical implications of using sensitive topics for entertainment and the need to foster empathy and understanding of historical events.

Miss USA 2015

The controversy surrounding the 2015 Miss USA pageant, mainly due to co-owner Donald Trump’s inflammatory remarks about Mexican immigrants during the presidential campaign, raised questions about the pageant’s political neutrality and ethical standards. Critics argued that the pageant’s association with Trump compromised its credibility and integrity.

Miss World 1970

The protests against the 1970 Miss World pageant in London by the Women’s Liberation Movement highlighted concerns about the pageant’s role in perpetuating patriarchal norms and objectifying women. Critics argued that the pageant reinforced outdated notions of femininity and beauty standards, contributing to the marginalization of women.

Miss Black America 1968

Created in response to the lack of representation of African American women in mainstream beauty pageants, Miss Black America faced criticism for segregating beauty standards based on race. Critics argued that race-specific pageants perpetuated divisions and reinforced stereotypes. In today’s increasingly diverse society, debates would center on the balance between promoting representation and inclusion and avoiding segregation based on race.

Miss Teenage America 1985

The Miss Teenage America pageant, focusing on adolescent girls, would spark debates about the sexualization of young women and the pressure to conform to adult beauty standards at a young age. Critics argue that such pageants contribute to the objectification and exploitation of teenage girls. Today, discussions would focus on the need to protect the well-being and self-esteem of young women and the importance of promoting positive body image and self-confidence independent of external validation.